Posts

Showing posts from 2009

MULTIPLE MANIFESTO DEMOCRATIC PRESS THEORY

Image
Having analyzed all the press theories, I have formulated one of my own, based on the lapses or weaknesses in some theories and strengths in others. The Multiple Manifesto Democratic Press Theory, as I put it, describes how the press should behave in a political system where the government is tuned or directed towards specific terms of reference or a “National Policy Guidance Book”. I have realised that, during elections in a democratic state, all the aspiring political parties present their ideologies or party promises in a codified volume called a Manifesto. It is this promises that the electorate or citizens are influenced by in their decision towards choosing their next president. When the chosen political party comes to power therefore, it is this manifesto through which the citizens judge their performance to see if they really stuck to the script of fulfilling their campaign promises. Under the Multiple Manifesto Democratic Press Theory therefore, all the political parties...

AUTHORITARIAN THEORY

The press under the authoritarian press theory is expected to be highly limited in their level of freedom. The level of a country’s democracy is measured by how liberal the press is and in an authoritarian regime, where democracy is not practiced at all, one can confidently say that the press is solely owned and controlled by the government. Under this theory, the press is seen as an ally and a tool for projecting governmental ideas and policies to the rest of the citizens. Principal members of the press, such as editors, are selected by government, thus they are mostly governmental officials or affiliates. In this way the direction of the press is geared towards that of the government. One can argue to some extent that, one feature of this theory which may be seen in the positive light is that which criminalises free speech, that is, editorial attacks or criticisms on governmental officials or politicians. In this way, objectivity in reportage is highly efficient, where due to the pos...

LIBERTARIAN THEORY

The rise of democracy, personal freedom and libertarian ideas by philosophers like John Milton and John Locke led to the undermining and end to authoritarian ideas and practices. The libertarian theory therefore demanded that the press or media is not owned or controlled by the government but rather should be seen as the fourth estate of the realm. In this case, the press is to act as a watchdog over all the other three arms of government and play a gate-keeping role by providing information to the public on governmental practices and decisions, exposing corrupt individuals and also serving government with the demands interests of the citizens. Thus, they have the freedom to publish without prior censorship or restriction and freedom of the press is greatly advocated. Critically speaking, the behaviour of the press in this system, conflicts greatly with the underlying ethics o the practice of journalism, that is, objectivity. This is because, in playing the gate-keeping role, the media...

SOVIET COMMUNIST PRESS THEORY

The Soviet Communist Press Theory was supported by the communist ideology of Karl Marx and Frederiche Engels who proposed a system where power or governmental rule lay amongst just a few in the society who were judged to be the elite or high in social class. They went further to predict that there would be a revolution in which individuals of the lower social class would overthrow those in power to form a classless or egalitarian society where everyone shared equal power and status. The media was therefore supposed to amplify or bring to light, the concerns of the working class or less influential in society. They were not owned by the government but were to some extent controlled by it. The media was also not to be under private control and also be self-regulatory. This type of media was similar to that of the authoritarian theory in some way but the difference was that, the authoritarian theory was totalitarian in nature. They opposed the liber...

SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY THEORY

The only thing missing from the libertarian ideology was the concept of social responsibility according to the Hutchins Commission in 1947. In as much as the freedom of the press is vital, it is accompanied by a certain level of responsibility in the form of obligatory social functions to the citizens. They are to inform the citizens and create a uniform platform for different ideas and opinions. Because this theory is closely related to the libertarian theory, the media here is not owned or controlled by the government. Independence of the media is thus emphasized and also accompanied by certain responsibilities or functions. The media is therefore supposed to meet certain standards. However, one can argue that, just like what happens in the industries where they fail to meet their social responsibility goals, the media may also cat in the same fashion by failing t o meet set standards and not reporting objectively. This may be attributed to the level pf freedom enjoyed by the press i...