CULTIVATION THEORY-Gerbner
1. INTRODUCTION
Cultivation theory, sometimes referred to as Cultivation analysis first appeared in the 1976 Journal of Communication titled “Living with Television: The violence profile”. The 1960’s and 1970’s were periods when interest in television, as a social force had reached its highest point. More specifically, people were interested especially in how television was related to the increasing individual and societal violence, at the time. For this reason, several researches were organized. Notable of these were the National Commission on the Causes and Prevention of Violence, organized in 1967 and 1968, and another in 1972 by the Surgeon General’s Scientific Advisory Committee on Television and Social Behavior respectively. Incidentally, George Gerbner, the proponent of Cultivation theory, was involved in both researches. With what started as a research on the “Violence Index” and then to the “Cultural Indicators Project”, George Gerbner and his associates produced the theory of Cultivation Analysis.
2. WHAT IS CULTIVATION THEORY?
Cultivation Analysis is the theory that explains the effects of television viewing on people’s perceptions, attitudes and values. This theory represented a shift from the limited effects paradigm of Paul Lazarsfeld that had dominated the 1940s. It focused on violence in television programmes, as a unit of analysis. Cultivation theory is accepted by some researchers to be a “stalagmite” theory because it suggests that media effects occur like the slow buildup of formations on cave floors, which take their interesting forms after eons of the steady dripping of limewater from the cave ceilings above.
George Gerbner established the “Cultural Indicators” research project, to study whether and how watching television may influence viewers' ideas of what the everyday world is like and as a result came up with this theory.
The Cultivation theory is based on certain principles that:
• The theory suggests television is responsible for shaping, or ‘cultivating’ viewers’ conceptions of social reality.
• The combined effect of massive television exposure by viewers over time subtly shapes the perception of social reality for individuals and, ultimately, for our culture as a whole
• Cultivation theorists argue that television has long-term effects which are small, gradual, indirect but cumulative and significant (the stalagmite concept).
It is common to see books quoting years like 1980 and 1970 as the official period when the theory was introduced. This is however understandable as the research covered a span of twenty years with subsequent revisions and updates to its contents in response to scholarly criticisms. The original research actually occurred between 1960 and 1980 to allow for adequate data collection and interpretation.
3. GERBNER’S RESEARCH
To have a thorough understanding of this theory, one has to scrutinize the exact research method employed by the researchers, to comprehend the premise upon which this theory is based. Gerbner’s research design was seen as complex to many scientists as it involved several operational definitions and multiple research methods mainly including Content Analysis on one
hand and a Survey on the other. These methods were employed continuously over a 20 year period to gather enough information for a thorough observation and analysis. Generally, Gerbner and his team of researchers developed a Message system analysis (content analysis), formulated questionnaires to conduct a survey of the audience and compared the social realities of light and heavy viewers with respect to television programmes.
3.1 Assumptions:
The cultural indicators research made five assumptions, they are:
Television is essentially and fundamentally different from other forms of mass media
The medium is the “central cultural arm” of American society
The substance of the consciousness cultivated by TV is not so much specific attitudes and opinions as more basic assumptions about the facts of life and standards of judgement on which conclusions are based” (Gerbner & Gross, 1978,).
Television’s major cultural function is to stabilise social patterns, to cultivate resistance to change
The observable, measurable, independent contributions of television to the culture are relatively small
3.2 Analysis of Television Content
According to Gerbner, violence was what viewers saw in their daily devotion to television and he was especially concerned that it “cultivated” the view among people that the world was a violent place. He defined the concept of “Dramatic Violence” as “the overt expression of physical force
(with or without a weapon), compelling action against one’s will on pain of being hurt and/or killed or threatened to be so victimized, as part of the plot.”
Gerbner and his team of researchers, as part of their cultural indicators research, started off by randomly selecting a week during the autumn season and documented every prime time television programme. For the purpose of their study, they defined television primetime as the time period between 8:00pm and 11:00pm daily. They also included programmes for children on weekends (Saturday and Sunday) between 8:00am and 2:00pm. Gerbner and his team of researchers then proceeded to record all incidents that fit their operational definition, to obtain frequencies of occurrence. They were able to determine the level of violence within these programmes with a formula that included the ratio of programmes that scripted violence, the rate of violence in the programmes that did and the percentage of characters involved in physical harm and killing. They found that the annual index was remarkably stable. With one half of his data collection complete, which was, knowledge television’s violent content, Gerbner then preceded to the next phase of is research, the survey.
3.3 Building a viewer profile through survey
Gerbner and his team of researchers gathered surveys of viewer attitudes and behaviours. His questions helped him to establish a categorization of respondents into Heavy and Light viewers. Gerbner identified Heavy watchers as those that watched television for over 4 hours per day and Light Watchers as those that did same for less than 2 hours per day. He predicted that heavy viewers saw the world as more dangerous than light viewers.
Gerbner also targeted four attitudes with his survey:
1. Chances of Involvement with violence.
2. Fear of walking alone at night
3. Perceived activity of police
4. General mistrust of people
4. FINDINGS
Gerbner and his team of researchers analyzed their findings with regards to heavy and light watchers and identified that for:
Chances of Involvement with violence
Light viewers predicted their weekly odds of being involved in violence were 1 in 100 while heavy viewers said it they were 1 in 10.
Fear of walking alone at night
Women were more afraid than men, but both sexes who were heavy viewers, overestimated criminal activity, believing it to be ten times more than figures indicate.
Perceived activity of police
Heavy viewers believed that about 5% of society is involved with law enforcement. In comparison, light viewers estimated 1 %.
General mistrust of people
People who were heavy viewers tended to see other people’s actions and motives more negatively. Gerbner called this “the mean world syndrome”
After gathering up his data from analysis of television content and responses from his survey, based on this research, Gerbner sought to quantify in percentage terms the differences in the answers of light and heavy television viewers about violence in the world. He did this by correlating the data from his content analysis of television with survey data from people. He called this “the cultivation differential.”
Gerbner then came to the conclusion that heavy viewers were susceptible to a perception that the world was a dangerous place
5. CRITIQUES
Gerbner’s work attracted many criticisms the world over. Some were concerned about the limitation of the study to the television medium and others were at sea with regards to the methodology employed. Critics also faulted cultivation analysis theory for relying too heavily on a broad definition of violence. They argue that because violence means different things to different subgroups and individuals, any claim that a clear message of violence could be understood in the same way by an entire culture is false. Rubin, Perse and Taylor (1988) for instance were of the view that Gerbner’s research was too general and had an “across-the-board”
effect. They contended that reactions were program-specific and as such a generalization could only be made if other variables apart from violence were observed and the responses analysed.
Paul Hirsch (1980) was perhaps Gerbner’s biggest critic. He stated that Gerbner’s research did not do an adequate job of controlling other variables. He wrote extensively on this point and attempted to produce evidence to support his claim. Hirsch (1980, cited in Livingstone 1990, p. 16), argued that an apparent relationship between exposure to violence on television and fear of crime can be explained by the neighbourhood viewers live in. Those who live in high-crime areas are more likely to stay at home and watch television and also to believe that they have a greater chance of being attacked than are those in low-crime areas. This critique would necessarily extend to other studies involving cultivation analysis.
6. RESPONSE TO CRITICISMS
In response to the criticisms, Morgan and Shanahan identified that the criticisms were politically motivated and also over critical of the research method employed. They highlighted the knowledge that some political players had of the power of television which they employed in their campaign to come into office. Funding researches to criticize Gerbner’s Cultivation Analysis was therefore a way of attacking the credibility of the research, thus, reducing public interest and knowledge of the effects of television viewing on their perceptions.
Also, they believed that by criticizing the research method that Gerbner and his team employed, critics failed to identify other very important aspects of the research such as the import of the study and its findings.
Gerbner and his team also went back to the drawing board, in an attempt to fine-tune their research by taking into considerations some of the issues raised by critics which they saw as legitimate. As a result, they introduced the concept of Mainstreaming and Resonance.
6.1 MAINSTREAMING
Mainstreaming is the view that, people’s life experiences may moderate the cultivation effect. It occurs when heavy viewing leads to a convergence of outlooks across groups. That is, the process of blurring, blending and bending. Through constant exposure to the same images and labels, heavy viewers develop a commonality of outlook.
6.2 RESONANCE
Resonance also purports that actual trauma can be caused by personal experience. A repeated symbolic portrayal of that experience on TV screen can cause the viewer to replay the real life experience over and over again. This means that people create reality or perceptions of the world based on previous life experiences they have gone through and such incidence of occurrence on television are just retrieval cues.
7. CONCLUSION
Gerbner’s cultivation theory says that television has become the main source of storytelling in today's society. Those who watch four or more hours a day are labeled heavy television viewers and those who view less than four hours per day, according to Gerbner are light viewers. Heavy viewers are exposed to more violence and therefore are affected by the Mean World Syndrome,
an idea that the world is worse than it actually is. According to Gerbner, the overuse of television is creating a homogeneous and fearful populace.
Epistemologically Gerbner believes in one truth. The theory does not believe television viewers have a choice in whether they are affected by media violence or not. Gerbner allows some of his own values to enter into the theory by deciding what to consider violence and by assigning a numerical value to heavy television viewing. While the theory does contain some issues it adequately opens the discussion dealing with effects of the media upon viewers.
The effects of this theory can be seen in our present media system. Examples such as Arnold Schwazznegger’s use of television fame to win the seat of Governor of Carlifornia and Ronald Regan as United States President all go to confirm that indeed, television viewing does have some cumulative effect on viewers. It is still a very relevant theory which needs to be applied to other media such as radio and the internet which are also media with powerful effects. In this way, the theory can gain more grounds in communication by cutting across all media to ascertain truth.
Key Terms
Violence Index: Annual content analysis of a sample week of network television prime-time fare demonstrating how much violence is present.
Cultural Indicators Project: In cultivation analysis, periodic examinations of television programming and the conceptions of social reality cultivated by viewing.
Light viewers: People who watch television for less than 2 hours in a day.
Heavy viewers: People who watch television for more than 4 hours in a day.
The Cultivation Differential: Quantification (in percentage terms) the differences in the answers of light and heavy television viewers about violence in the world
REFERENCES
Baran, S. J. & Davis, K. D. (2010). Mass Communication Theory: Foundations, Ferment and Future. (6th ed). Boston MA: Wadsworth.
Griffin, E. (1991). A First Look at Communication Theory. (5th ed). McGraw Hill.
Livingstone, S. (1990): Making Sense of Television. London: Pergamon
Lule, J. (1996). Understanding Media and Culture: An Introduction to Mass Communication. NC: Flat World Knowledge.
Severin, Werner, J. & Tankard, W. J. (2001). Communication Theories: Origins, methods, and uses in the mass media. NY: Hastings House.
Shanahan, J. & Morgan, M., (1999). Television and its Viewers: Cultivation Theory and Research. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Cultivation theory, sometimes referred to as Cultivation analysis first appeared in the 1976 Journal of Communication titled “Living with Television: The violence profile”. The 1960’s and 1970’s were periods when interest in television, as a social force had reached its highest point. More specifically, people were interested especially in how television was related to the increasing individual and societal violence, at the time. For this reason, several researches were organized. Notable of these were the National Commission on the Causes and Prevention of Violence, organized in 1967 and 1968, and another in 1972 by the Surgeon General’s Scientific Advisory Committee on Television and Social Behavior respectively. Incidentally, George Gerbner, the proponent of Cultivation theory, was involved in both researches. With what started as a research on the “Violence Index” and then to the “Cultural Indicators Project”, George Gerbner and his associates produced the theory of Cultivation Analysis.
2. WHAT IS CULTIVATION THEORY?
Cultivation Analysis is the theory that explains the effects of television viewing on people’s perceptions, attitudes and values. This theory represented a shift from the limited effects paradigm of Paul Lazarsfeld that had dominated the 1940s. It focused on violence in television programmes, as a unit of analysis. Cultivation theory is accepted by some researchers to be a “stalagmite” theory because it suggests that media effects occur like the slow buildup of formations on cave floors, which take their interesting forms after eons of the steady dripping of limewater from the cave ceilings above.
George Gerbner established the “Cultural Indicators” research project, to study whether and how watching television may influence viewers' ideas of what the everyday world is like and as a result came up with this theory.
The Cultivation theory is based on certain principles that:
• The theory suggests television is responsible for shaping, or ‘cultivating’ viewers’ conceptions of social reality.
• The combined effect of massive television exposure by viewers over time subtly shapes the perception of social reality for individuals and, ultimately, for our culture as a whole
• Cultivation theorists argue that television has long-term effects which are small, gradual, indirect but cumulative and significant (the stalagmite concept).
It is common to see books quoting years like 1980 and 1970 as the official period when the theory was introduced. This is however understandable as the research covered a span of twenty years with subsequent revisions and updates to its contents in response to scholarly criticisms. The original research actually occurred between 1960 and 1980 to allow for adequate data collection and interpretation.
3. GERBNER’S RESEARCH
To have a thorough understanding of this theory, one has to scrutinize the exact research method employed by the researchers, to comprehend the premise upon which this theory is based. Gerbner’s research design was seen as complex to many scientists as it involved several operational definitions and multiple research methods mainly including Content Analysis on one
hand and a Survey on the other. These methods were employed continuously over a 20 year period to gather enough information for a thorough observation and analysis. Generally, Gerbner and his team of researchers developed a Message system analysis (content analysis), formulated questionnaires to conduct a survey of the audience and compared the social realities of light and heavy viewers with respect to television programmes.
3.1 Assumptions:
The cultural indicators research made five assumptions, they are:
Television is essentially and fundamentally different from other forms of mass media
The medium is the “central cultural arm” of American society
The substance of the consciousness cultivated by TV is not so much specific attitudes and opinions as more basic assumptions about the facts of life and standards of judgement on which conclusions are based” (Gerbner & Gross, 1978,).
Television’s major cultural function is to stabilise social patterns, to cultivate resistance to change
The observable, measurable, independent contributions of television to the culture are relatively small
3.2 Analysis of Television Content
According to Gerbner, violence was what viewers saw in their daily devotion to television and he was especially concerned that it “cultivated” the view among people that the world was a violent place. He defined the concept of “Dramatic Violence” as “the overt expression of physical force
(with or without a weapon), compelling action against one’s will on pain of being hurt and/or killed or threatened to be so victimized, as part of the plot.”
Gerbner and his team of researchers, as part of their cultural indicators research, started off by randomly selecting a week during the autumn season and documented every prime time television programme. For the purpose of their study, they defined television primetime as the time period between 8:00pm and 11:00pm daily. They also included programmes for children on weekends (Saturday and Sunday) between 8:00am and 2:00pm. Gerbner and his team of researchers then proceeded to record all incidents that fit their operational definition, to obtain frequencies of occurrence. They were able to determine the level of violence within these programmes with a formula that included the ratio of programmes that scripted violence, the rate of violence in the programmes that did and the percentage of characters involved in physical harm and killing. They found that the annual index was remarkably stable. With one half of his data collection complete, which was, knowledge television’s violent content, Gerbner then preceded to the next phase of is research, the survey.
3.3 Building a viewer profile through survey
Gerbner and his team of researchers gathered surveys of viewer attitudes and behaviours. His questions helped him to establish a categorization of respondents into Heavy and Light viewers. Gerbner identified Heavy watchers as those that watched television for over 4 hours per day and Light Watchers as those that did same for less than 2 hours per day. He predicted that heavy viewers saw the world as more dangerous than light viewers.
Gerbner also targeted four attitudes with his survey:
1. Chances of Involvement with violence.
2. Fear of walking alone at night
3. Perceived activity of police
4. General mistrust of people
4. FINDINGS
Gerbner and his team of researchers analyzed their findings with regards to heavy and light watchers and identified that for:
Chances of Involvement with violence
Light viewers predicted their weekly odds of being involved in violence were 1 in 100 while heavy viewers said it they were 1 in 10.
Fear of walking alone at night
Women were more afraid than men, but both sexes who were heavy viewers, overestimated criminal activity, believing it to be ten times more than figures indicate.
Perceived activity of police
Heavy viewers believed that about 5% of society is involved with law enforcement. In comparison, light viewers estimated 1 %.
General mistrust of people
People who were heavy viewers tended to see other people’s actions and motives more negatively. Gerbner called this “the mean world syndrome”
After gathering up his data from analysis of television content and responses from his survey, based on this research, Gerbner sought to quantify in percentage terms the differences in the answers of light and heavy television viewers about violence in the world. He did this by correlating the data from his content analysis of television with survey data from people. He called this “the cultivation differential.”
Gerbner then came to the conclusion that heavy viewers were susceptible to a perception that the world was a dangerous place
5. CRITIQUES
Gerbner’s work attracted many criticisms the world over. Some were concerned about the limitation of the study to the television medium and others were at sea with regards to the methodology employed. Critics also faulted cultivation analysis theory for relying too heavily on a broad definition of violence. They argue that because violence means different things to different subgroups and individuals, any claim that a clear message of violence could be understood in the same way by an entire culture is false. Rubin, Perse and Taylor (1988) for instance were of the view that Gerbner’s research was too general and had an “across-the-board”
effect. They contended that reactions were program-specific and as such a generalization could only be made if other variables apart from violence were observed and the responses analysed.
Paul Hirsch (1980) was perhaps Gerbner’s biggest critic. He stated that Gerbner’s research did not do an adequate job of controlling other variables. He wrote extensively on this point and attempted to produce evidence to support his claim. Hirsch (1980, cited in Livingstone 1990, p. 16), argued that an apparent relationship between exposure to violence on television and fear of crime can be explained by the neighbourhood viewers live in. Those who live in high-crime areas are more likely to stay at home and watch television and also to believe that they have a greater chance of being attacked than are those in low-crime areas. This critique would necessarily extend to other studies involving cultivation analysis.
6. RESPONSE TO CRITICISMS
In response to the criticisms, Morgan and Shanahan identified that the criticisms were politically motivated and also over critical of the research method employed. They highlighted the knowledge that some political players had of the power of television which they employed in their campaign to come into office. Funding researches to criticize Gerbner’s Cultivation Analysis was therefore a way of attacking the credibility of the research, thus, reducing public interest and knowledge of the effects of television viewing on their perceptions.
Also, they believed that by criticizing the research method that Gerbner and his team employed, critics failed to identify other very important aspects of the research such as the import of the study and its findings.
Gerbner and his team also went back to the drawing board, in an attempt to fine-tune their research by taking into considerations some of the issues raised by critics which they saw as legitimate. As a result, they introduced the concept of Mainstreaming and Resonance.
6.1 MAINSTREAMING
Mainstreaming is the view that, people’s life experiences may moderate the cultivation effect. It occurs when heavy viewing leads to a convergence of outlooks across groups. That is, the process of blurring, blending and bending. Through constant exposure to the same images and labels, heavy viewers develop a commonality of outlook.
6.2 RESONANCE
Resonance also purports that actual trauma can be caused by personal experience. A repeated symbolic portrayal of that experience on TV screen can cause the viewer to replay the real life experience over and over again. This means that people create reality or perceptions of the world based on previous life experiences they have gone through and such incidence of occurrence on television are just retrieval cues.
7. CONCLUSION
Gerbner’s cultivation theory says that television has become the main source of storytelling in today's society. Those who watch four or more hours a day are labeled heavy television viewers and those who view less than four hours per day, according to Gerbner are light viewers. Heavy viewers are exposed to more violence and therefore are affected by the Mean World Syndrome,
an idea that the world is worse than it actually is. According to Gerbner, the overuse of television is creating a homogeneous and fearful populace.
Epistemologically Gerbner believes in one truth. The theory does not believe television viewers have a choice in whether they are affected by media violence or not. Gerbner allows some of his own values to enter into the theory by deciding what to consider violence and by assigning a numerical value to heavy television viewing. While the theory does contain some issues it adequately opens the discussion dealing with effects of the media upon viewers.
The effects of this theory can be seen in our present media system. Examples such as Arnold Schwazznegger’s use of television fame to win the seat of Governor of Carlifornia and Ronald Regan as United States President all go to confirm that indeed, television viewing does have some cumulative effect on viewers. It is still a very relevant theory which needs to be applied to other media such as radio and the internet which are also media with powerful effects. In this way, the theory can gain more grounds in communication by cutting across all media to ascertain truth.
Key Terms
Violence Index: Annual content analysis of a sample week of network television prime-time fare demonstrating how much violence is present.
Cultural Indicators Project: In cultivation analysis, periodic examinations of television programming and the conceptions of social reality cultivated by viewing.
Light viewers: People who watch television for less than 2 hours in a day.
Heavy viewers: People who watch television for more than 4 hours in a day.
The Cultivation Differential: Quantification (in percentage terms) the differences in the answers of light and heavy television viewers about violence in the world
REFERENCES
Baran, S. J. & Davis, K. D. (2010). Mass Communication Theory: Foundations, Ferment and Future. (6th ed). Boston MA: Wadsworth.
Griffin, E. (1991). A First Look at Communication Theory. (5th ed). McGraw Hill.
Livingstone, S. (1990): Making Sense of Television. London: Pergamon
Lule, J. (1996). Understanding Media and Culture: An Introduction to Mass Communication. NC: Flat World Knowledge.
Severin, Werner, J. & Tankard, W. J. (2001). Communication Theories: Origins, methods, and uses in the mass media. NY: Hastings House.
Shanahan, J. & Morgan, M., (1999). Television and its Viewers: Cultivation Theory and Research. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Comments
Post a Comment