MEDIA AND POLITICS: MEDIA’S ROLE IN ELECTIONS
School of Communication Studies, University of Ghana.
Mass Media, Culture and Society
Mass Media, Culture and Society
Kennedy Aryeetey Tetteh
Introduction
Several
authorities have offered extensive definitions of Politics. David Easton
defines it as “the authoritative allocation of values of a society”. Harold
Laswell (1936) also believes that politics is a process of decision making as
to “who gets what, when and how” whether it is at the macro level, where the
highest level of politics (governance) is practiced or the micro level where
political power is exercised over a relatively small group. These definitions
of politics raise serious questions as to how the allocation of power is made
to an individual or a group, which gives them that authority to make decisions
as to who gets what. Secondly, once this power is allocated, who ensures that
it is not abused and in what ways is this mandate carried out? Finally with so
much power vested in a group or individual how do they relate with these
institutions that are mandated to scrutinize them?
Within the
different systems of governance, specific institutions may be assigned this
role of safeguarding allocated power and this is no different from the democratic
political system where the media, by constitution or social contract, performs
this role. Also, since the concept of democracy is underpinned by some libertarian
ideologies the political players themselves (Politicians) may use the media in
particular ways which make the relationship between media and politics
symbiotic.
With features
like a constitution, voting and elections, an analysis of the media’s role in
political life in general and specifically in an election will help throw more
light on the ways in which political power is safeguarded and how the
politicians themselves use the media to their own benefit.
Media’s role in Political life general
The role of the
media within a democratic system of governance can be categorized under three
main forms; the gatekeeping role,
watchdog role and ensuring accountability.
The role of the media as gatekeepers is
implicit in the literal definition of the word. The media should control what
“comes in” and “goes out” as far as society is concerned. They are supposed to
ensure that media texts have a balance of opinions by filtering what
politicians put out into society and those that come from society itself.
According to Pippa Norris (2010):
“As gatekeepers,
the news media have a responsibility to reflect and incorporate the plurality of viewpoints and
political persuasions in reporting, to maximize the diversity of perspectives and arguments heard in rational
public deliberations, and to enrich the public sphere.”(p.5)
In this way, the
media ensures that parties on both sides of the debate, that is, the citizens
and government have fair representation and there are enough issues within the
public sphere to deliberate on.
Guarding public
interest is the utmost priority in the media’s obligation to society as
watchdogs. This is closely tied to the media’s role of ensuring accountability
by highlighting the activities of politicians especially in cases of abuse of
incumbency, corruption and malfeasance. This helps to strengthen transparency
and effectiveness of governance.
The media’s responsibility in ensuring
accountability is in two forms; holding politicians accountable to office in
the light of their assigned roles and mandates and as previously highlighted,
holding the government accountable to society.
Media’s Role in elections
Elections are one of the most sensitive and
crucial activities in a democracy. It is “the process by which people with the
same political aspirations are able to elect or select their leaders without
resorting to violence but through the ballot box” (Giovanni Sartori 1976).
Because the issue of elections is of importance to all citizens, several
institutions, during this period perform specific functions as part of a
consolidated effort to ensure peaceful elections. Advocacy groups embark on
peace campaigns, some governmental institutions in charge of civic education
try to explain the election procedure to the citizenry and politicians
themselves embark on rallies and campaign activities.
Agenda
Setting
The media’s role in an election is mainly
centered on Agenda Setting which is
accompanied by priming, balance and fairness and where necessary, the concept
of peace
journalism. As agenda setters,
the news media have a responsibility to raise awareness of pervasive
social problems, helping to turn public attention to matters of common interest
including social needs, development issues, personality profiles and all other
matters that can help citizens make an informed decision in the election. The
issue of salience comes in here where the media decides which specific
information, with regards to the election period, what will be most relevant to
report on. Ideally, the media is not supposed to be opinionated in carrying out
this mandate but rather put out salient issues objectively for deliberation by
society. Information used in setting the agenda for discussion during an
election can range from debates on party manifestos, issues of development,
campaign messages and promises, official statements by political party leaders
and authorities as well as party activities.
Priming
As part of the agenda setting process, the
media throws more light on political figures, especially those in contention to
contest for political power. They trace their history and contribution to local
or national politics, examine their campaign messages and assess their
capabilities. In the course of doing so they may chance upon some information
that may suggest incompetence but as objectivity is the central driving force,
the media may be compelled to report on that as well.
Balance and
fairness
In an election, due to multiplicity of issues,
financial backing and active engagement of political figures and parties in
social activities, there may be more publicity or visibility for some
politicians than others. It is the responsibility of the media to ensure equal representation
of all political parties in terms of time allocation for broadcasting and
balanced reportage in newspapers and on websites. Some television stations
specifically interview political candidates either as a group or individually
to highlight their profiles and allow for the general public to judge for
themselves. Newspapers and webpages normally do editorials or features to cover
personality profiles.
In an attempt to create balance in representation,
the content of such news reports are also supposed to be a fair reflection of
what issues really are on the ground. Reports should not be suggestive of partisanship
and bias towards a particular individual and party.
Peace journalism
Due to the high
stakes involved, elections may be one of the most “verbally-abusive” periods
where politicians make serious insinuations about each other. Some of these
utterances may have ripple effects that that can cause violent reactions or
responses from party-faithfuls. In the media’s attempt to report the truth and
facts, they must be diligent enough to filter out these words and accusations
to report only on clear issues which are devoid of inciting violence. In some
countries, the media decides to avoid publishing hate speech or reporting on
violent actions as well as blaming individuals for such actions. They tend to
portray unity after the election in setting the agenda by ensuring that the
country is made bigger than any single individual. The decision of
self-censorship among some journalists during the post-election war in Northern
Uganda is an example of how peace journalism is applied by the media.
The specific ways in which the media
carries out its agenda setting role in an election is seen through the
particular types of programmes that are portrayed in the various media.
Originally, the traditional media has been the main channel through which media
messages are disseminated but the advent of social media powered by new media
technologies has added a different dimension to this function where there is
real-time communication between users and more importantly citizen journalism,
accomplished through blogging and status updates (micro-blogging).
The print media, that is, newspapers,
magazines and such media platforms perform their agenda setting roles mainly
through publishing editorials, features, articles and hard news stories. There
is also the more satirical use of political cartoons in this process. The
electronic media particularly radio and television, are flooded with newspaper
reviews and several news bulletins in the day as well as major news bulletins
with an extensive coverage on election issues. These particular media also
allow for campaign ads to be broadcast on their platforms. Television being an audio-visual medium,
allows some extra options in broadcasting such as political trails where
extensive coverage of presidential debates, party campaigns including rallies
and congresses are accommodated. This medium is also used to host election
programmes such as Wolf Blitzer’s Election Night on CNN and Ghana Decides on
TV3. New and Social Media has content of both the print media and electronic
media, making it a multimedia platform. It also allows for publishing of
stories, sometimes accompanied by video and audio pieces and podcasts. Because
of the real-time and interactive nature of this medium also, it allows for a
point of convergence or mobilized action. These were seen in events that led to
the Arab Spring and riots in Libya.
Case Study-The media’s Agenda Setting in
Liberian election
In November 2005 Ellen Johnson-Sirleaf, was
elected Africa’s first female president, in the Liberian presidential election
runoff. The media in this election was said to have set the agenda by
highlighting the strengths of both candidates Ellen Johnson-Sirleaf and former FIFA world best player George Weah
being “qualification and experience”’ and “common sense and popularity”
respectively. After beating his opponent by a wide margin in the first two
rounds, George Weah however lost the runoff election. It is argued that the
threats made by George Weah, in the run up to the run-off, where he stated
clearly that he would teach the media a lesson when he comes to power accounted
for his loss since the media used his statement in setting the agenda for
discussion in that run-off.
This incident shows the effectiveness of
the media’s role in setting the agenda in an election.
Influence of ownership and control
The issue of
ownership has always been of great concern to the media’s role in an election.
The media, being a specialized agency, with clearly spelt out codes and ethics
is mandated to report truth and in so doing be fair and objective. However,
some media houses, as a result of the influence of ownership are unable to
adequately carry out their mandate in society. Most politicians now own media
houses across different media forms, making them partisan and directly biased
in their reportage. Such media houses cannot be seen as objective because they
tend to frame their news stories in support of the political parties to which
their owners belong.
Research
conducted by the Media Foundation for West Africa showed that Oman Fm, at a point
in Ghana’s 2012 general elections led in the use of abusive language on air
closely followed by Radio Gold. It is interesting to note that both radio
stations are alleged to be owned by politicians and thus are greatly biased
towards the political party which they represent. This phenomenon goes a long
way to show that media ownership can greatly affect the role of the media in
political life and subsequently in an election.
However a
peaceful resolution to this anomaly rests in the power of the audience or users
of media texts, in this case the voters, to select a particular type of media
to fulfill a particular purpose. Buttressed by the Uses and Gratification
theory, this concept explains that eligible voters in an election can either
decide to read newspapers, listen to radio, watch television or go online to
obtain information during the election period. What this does is that, it helps
to either confirm or deny an assertion or some information that a voter is unclear
about due to the multiplicity of channels to select from as sources of news. In
this way, the influence of biased media that tend to frame stories subjectively
is minimized since there are several avenues for confirmation.
Political uses of the media
With the relationship between media and
politics being symbiotic, political figures, especially candidates in an
election also use the media in various ways. Politicians generally use the
media as their main source of mass communication to send information to the
citizens and also as a channel for feedback to assess their performance.
However, in an election, this function takes on a whole new turn; it becomes
more strategic and tactical to impact on citizens meaningfully so as to
influence public opinion.
One of the ways
in which politicians use the media in an election is in Image construction.
Politicians, being aware of the extra attention they receive in the media ensure
that they portray themselves in the most desirable way whenever they get media
presence. Their style of dressing, demeanor, manner of speech and gestures tend
to communicate non-verbally to their audiences. A classic case is the portrayal
of President Obama in pictures during the run up to the 2008 American elections
which sought to portray him as a leader by constantly framing him in a landscape
mode photograph. The effect was that the photographs showed not only him the
speaker but the crowd which he spoke to, creating a resonating effect of a
leader, talking to his people. In this same vein, his campaign team presented
his opponent, John McCain as an old man in most photographs.
Politicians
also employ the concept of powerful effects of influence, such as popularity
within the media circles especially on television to elicit resonance in an
attempt to influence public opinion in an election. Gideon Aryeequaye, an ace broadcaster
as well as Kofi Asare Brako (Abatey) all used their popularity and media
presence as a tool to run their campaigns. Another dynamic to this situation is
that, politicians tend to include popular personalities, who have huge
followings, in their campaign, in a bid to win over all their supporters. President
John Dramani Mahama of Ghana had popular media personalities and celebrities
such actor John Dumello, radio broadcaster Abeeku Santana and Yaw Ampofo Ankrah
in his campaign team during the 2012 general elections in Ghana. In the global
circles President Ronald Reagan of the United States and governor Arnold Schwarzennegar
are good examples of television and film personalities who benefited from their
media fame to win political power.
Conclusion
The media’s role in an
election is mainly to set the agenda for discussion within the public sphere.
In doing so, the media is expected to be fair and balanced to all candidates
and political parties. They must take away personal biases from their reportage
and ensure that the general public is presented with unfiltered and unaltered
information. It is also clear that, problems of ownership and control can
affect the media in carrying out this duty but with the power that voters
possess, this influence should not have any significant impact since there will
be several ways in which information can be verified.
Politicians also tend to use
the media in many ways to their advantage in an election. They may construct a
desired image, draw from their popularity or quite simple use the media as
their official medium of communicating with the citizens. They may do this
through press releases that are published in newspapers, organizing press
conferences which will be televised and aired across several television
networks and radio stations or directly set up websites, blogs or social media
accounts where they can share their manifestos and engage in direct
interactions with prospective voters.
REFERENCES
Avle, S. Global Flows, Media
and Developing Democracies: the Ghanaian Case. Journal of
African Media Studies (Vol 3 issue 1)
Croteau, D., Hoynes, W.
& Milan, S. (2012). Media/Society:
Fourth Edition. Sage,
CA.USA
Easton, D. (1953). The Political
System: An Inquiry into the State of Political Science. New York.
Friedman, S. (2011). Whose
freedom? South Africa's press, middle-class bias and the threat of control. Ecquid Novi:
African Journalism Studies, 32:2, 106-121
Goretti, N. L. (2007). Peace
Journalism Applied: An assessment of media coverage of the conflict in Northern
Uganda. Conflict and Communication Online (Vol. 6., No. 2)
Norris, P. (2010) ed. Public Sentinel: News Media & Governance
Reform. The
International Bank
for Reconstruction and Development. Washington, D.C., U.S.A.
Sartori, G. (1976). Parties and Party Systems: A Framework for
Analysis. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press
Shaw S.I. (2007). The media's agenda-setting role in Liberia's 2005 presidential runoff election. Ecquid Novi:
African Journalism Studies, 28:1-2, 56-80
Social
Media and Postelection Crisis in Kenya (2008). Retrieved from
www.http://hij.sagepub.com/content/13/3/328
Comments
Post a Comment